Court Setback Puts Williams’ $1B Northeast Gas Pipeline Schedule at Risk
Philadelphia appeals court rejects developer bid to keep New Jersey permit in effect despite claim that delays could jeopardize project’s late-2027 finish.
A federal appeals court on Oct. 22 rejected energy developer Williams Cos.’ bid to keep a key New Jersey permit in effect for its more-than-$1-billion Northeast Supply Enhancement natural gas pipeline after the firm warned that losing the approval could delay construction and jeopardize the project’s late-2027 completion target.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in Philadelphia denied Williams unit Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Co.’s petition for panel and full-court rehearing of a Sept. 8 decision that vacated New Jersey’s water-quality certification under the federal Clean Water Act Section 401.
The denial now requires the New Jersey Dept. of Environmental Protection to return the certification to the agency for further proceedings. It may supplement its explanation, require additional analyses, issue a new or revised certification or reach a different result.
In its Sept. 22 rehearing petition, Transco said New Jersey construction had originally been set to begin Oct. 1 and acknowledged that vacating the certification “will delay construction” in the state. The company said delays could jeopardize its announced Nov. 1, 2027 in-service date and delivery of added natural gas to utility National Grid for the 2027-28 winter heating season.
That assessment was more urgent than Williams’ position immediately following the Sept. 8 decision. Williams spokesperson Cherice Corley said then that the company did not expect the ruling “to adversely affect project construction or the anticipated in-service timeline,” ENR reported Sept. 11.
Williams did not respond to a request for comment on the project’s construction schedule or whether Transco plans to seek further review from the U.S. Supreme Court.
New Jersey Work on Critical Path
The pipeline would add roughly 37 miles of pipeline and related facilities to Transco’s system, increasing capacity by 400,000 dekatherms per day to serve National Grid customers in New York City and Long Island.
Williams’ Northeast Supply Enhancement project includes a new compressor station in Somerset County, the Madison Loop in Middlesex County and the offshore Raritan Bay Loop. Transco says Station 206 is a critical-path component that will take about 13 months to build.
New Jersey work includes a compressor station in Somerset County, the 3.4-mile Madison Loop in Middlesex County and approximately six miles of offshore pipeline in Raritan Bay.
Transco told the court construction must begin in 2026 and finish in 2027 because the schedule incorporates onshore and offshore work, compressor-station construction, permit conditions and seasonal restrictions.
The company identified Compressor Station 206 as a critical-path component requiring about 13 months to build. Delaying its start could jeopardize the Nov. 1, 2027 service date, Transco said.
Transco also said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission cannot issue a notice to proceed for New Jersey components without a valid state water-quality certification. It asked the Philadelphia court to set a schedule requiring NJDEP to act in time for New Jersey construction to begin no later than Oct. 30.
The court denied rehearing without granting that relief.
“The court’s decision vacating the water quality certification stands and construction in New Jersey cannot go forward,” said Christopher Miller, executive director of Eastern Environmental Law Center, which represents the Baykeeper petitioner, in an Oct. 26 email.
The environmental deficiencies identified by the appeals court involve the Raritan Bay Loop, where Transco said construction was not set to start until March or April 2027. But the vacated certification also covers Compressor Station 206 and the Madison Loop, whose environmental impacts were not challenged in the appeal.
Map courtesy Williams Cos.